Not all pro-life Americans are religious, but religious Americans are more likely to be pro-life.
Americans’ views on the morality of abortion remain mixed in the days leading up to a Supreme Court decision that could overturn Roe v. Wade, but a majority favor restrictions that go beyond those currently allowed, according to a new study from the Land Center for Cultural Engagement at Southwestern Seminary conducted by Lifeway Research. In addition, those who self-identify with a religion, engage in religious practices like church attendance and hold evangelical beliefs are more likely to favor restrictions on abortion.
“This survey clearly demonstrates evangelical beliefs and practices, especially church attendance, translate into pro-life views,” said Adam W. Greenway, president of Southwestern Seminary. “This underscores the truth that the ultimate solution to this moral problem, like all moral problems, is spiritual transformation of the gospel of Jesus Christ among individuals that will eventually translate into societal changes.”
“Critical research is one part of the Land Center mission, and because of the long-standing commitment of Southern Baptists to the sanctity of human life, we focused on Americans’ abortion views as our first in-depth research project,” said Dan Darling, director of the Land Center. “This research provides information vital to equipping pastors and church leaders to understand this cultural moment and to shaping the moral consciences of God’s people. We expect to provide additional serious research on a variety of topics to help Christians engage our culture with gospel truth.”
Conducted days prior to the leak of a draft opinion by Justice Samuel Alito that indicated the Supreme Court planned to overturn the landmark decision that essentially legalized abortion throughout the United States, the study records Americans’ views on abortion, the beginning of life and what people want to happen in a potential post-Roe environment.
While increased church attendance correlates with pro-life perspectives, those who attend church say they don’t often hear about abortion on Sunday mornings. Two in 3 Americans who say they attend religious worship services a few times a year or more (66 percent) say they hear a teacher or clergy person mention the topic of abortion no more than once or twice a year, including 36 percent who say they never hear it spoken about. Few churchgoers, regardless of their perspective on abortion, want the church to talk about the issue less often. Overall, 46 percent say the topic is addressed the right amount, 38 percent want to hear about it more, and 16 percent want less.
Americans’ abortion views
Around 3 in 10 Americans hold generally pro-life views on abortion: 12 percent say abortion shouldn’t be legal in any situation, and 17 percent say it shouldn’t be legal in most situations. Another 21 percent say there are a variety of situations where it should be legal and illegal. More than 2 in 5 are generally pro-abortion rights, with 22 percent saying abortion should be legal in most situations and 24 percent saying it should be legal in any situation.
Pro-life views are more common than pro-abortion rights among Protestants (41 percent vs. 31 percent). Catholics (32 percent vs. 43 percent) and people from other faiths (31 percent to 47 percent) lean pro-abortion rights. The non-religious are overwhelmingly pro-abortion rights (11 percent pro-life vs. 70 percent pro-abortion rights).
Those with evangelical beliefs are more pro-life than pro-abortion rights (64 percent vs. 15 percent), while those without evangelical beliefs are the opposite (22 percent vs. 53 percent).
American Christians who attend church weekly are more than twice as likely to be generally pro-life (53 percent vs. 19 percent). Those who attend two to four times a month (28 percent vs. 36 percent) and those who attend less frequently (30 percent vs. 46 percent) are more likely to be pro-abortion rights.
For half of Americans (51 percent), one of the strongest factors in the development of their views on abortion is their views on women’s rights and freedoms. For more than 2 in 5 (43 percent), their views on morality and right and wrong play a strong role. More than a third point to views on health and medical issues (37 percent) or views on children’s rights and quality of life (34 percent). Three in 10 say their religious faith is a leading factor in the development of their abortion views (29 percent). Fewer point to their views on social issues (25 percent), views on economic issues or poverty (23 percent), views and experiences as a parent (20 percent), personal experience with the issue (18 percent) or the views of political leaders and party they support (5 percent).
Specifically among the generally pro-life, personal religious faith (58 percent), views on morality (56 percent) and views on children’s rights and quality of life (46 percent) are dominant factors contributing to their perspectives on abortion. Around 1 in 6 pro-life Americans say their views on women’s rights (16 percent) is one of the strongest factors in how their views on abortion were developed.
For those who are pro-abortion rights, views on women’s rights and freedoms (74 percent) dominate the other factors, which include views on health and medical issues (46 percent), views on social issues (36 percent), views on morality (35 percent) and views on economic issues (32 percent). Close to 1 in 10 (9 percent) point to their religious faith.
Among those who have a more mixed perspective or who are unsure about the issue, half point to women’s rights (51 percent) and a third (32 percent) mention their religious faith.
“Americans’ own descriptions of how their views on abortion developed have strikingly different origins,” said Scott McConnell, executive director of Lifeway Research. “While the issue has been heavily politicized, almost all Americans claim they had these views without the influence of political leaders. One group says they’re heavily influenced by their views on women’s freedoms and the other by their views on religious faith and morality.”
While abortion generates much debate and discussion, other issues are personally important to more people. Americans are more likely to say inflation (85 percent), voting rights and security (76 percent), national debt (71 percent), foreign policy (67 percent), climate change (66 percent), immigration (66 percent) and race relations (65 percent) are important or extremely important to them than abortion (64 percent). Fewer Americans say the same about prison reform (49 percent).
Those who are either generally pro-life and pro-abortion rights are more likely than those who have a mixed opinion to see abortion as extremely important and view it as a key when determining their vote. Among the two opposing perspectives, pro-life individuals place more political importance on the issue. Pro-life Americans are more likely to say abortion is extremely important (52 percent) than those who are pro-abortion rights (40 percent). When choosing a candidate, 40 percent of pro-life Americans say the candidate’s view on this issue has an extremely strong impact on their willingness to vote for that person, compared to 34 percent of pro-abortion rights Americans and 14 percent of those who are in the middle or unsure.
Mixed opinions on life and specifics
Americans have varying opinions on when human life actually begins and have complicated views on specific cases of abortion. Most say life begins at least by the first heartbeat detected, however, most also believe abortion should be legal if the child would be born with severe disabilities.
More than a third of Americans (35 percent) say life begins at conception, while 28 percent say at the first detected heartbeat. Almost 1 in 8 say life begins when the fetus is viable outside the womb (13 percent) or upon birth (13 percent). Few (2 percent) say at another point, and 10 percent say they honestly don’t know.
Protestants are most likely to say life begins at conception (49 percent), as are Americans of other faiths (39 percent). Catholics are most likely to say at the first detected heartbeat (40 percent). Religiously unaffiliated Americans are the most likely to say at birth (28 percent) and viability (20 percent). Americans with evangelical beliefs (66 percent) are more than twice as likely as non-evangelicals (29 percent) to say life begins at conception.
Most Christians who attend church weekly (56 percent) say life begins at conception, while those who attend less frequently are more evenly split between conception and the first heartbeat.
“Since the Roe v. Wade decision, it has been legal to end what the majority of Americans consider a human life,” said McConnell. “People’s perspectives on the start of life varies greatly by religious faith. Those with no religious affiliation are less likely than any other demographic group to say life begins by the time of the first heartbeat. This contrasts sharply with the almost 9 in 10 with evangelical beliefs who say it does.”
When asked specifically what time period they believe abortion should be a legal option assuming there are no health issues for the woman or the fetus, half of Americans say no later than 12 weeks (about 3 months), including 26 percent who say it shouldn’t be legal at any point, 15 percent who say up to six weeks and 11 percent who say up to 12 weeks. Fewer set the time frame at later dates, such as 15 weeks (7 percent), 20 weeks (6 percent), 24 weeks (4 percent), 28 weeks (4 percent) or up to birth (10 percent). Almost 1 in 6 (17 percent) say they aren’t sure.
Even among those who are not generally pro-life, there is broad consensus for abortion restrictions. Almost 3 in 5 Americans (59 percent) who are unsure or somewhere between pro-life and pro-abortion rights, favor limiting legal abortion to no later than 12 weeks. Among the pro-abortion rights, 50 percent place the limit somewhere prior to 20 weeks (about four and a half months).
Protestants (40 percent) are the most likely to never allow abortion assuming there are no health issues related to the pregnancy, followed by Catholics (26 percent), those of other faiths (25 percent) and the religiously unaffiliated (10 percent). Few Protestants (4 percent) or Catholics (3 percent) say they would allow abortion up to birth compared to 9 percent of those of other faiths and 22 percent of those with no religious affiliation.
Weekly churchgoers (52 percent) are more likely than those who attend less frequently (31 percent) or not at all (23 percent) to say abortion should not be legal at any point assuming there are no health issues.
When asked about specific circumstances related to the pregnancy, most Americans say abortion should be legal when the mom’s life is in danger (78 percent), the pregnancy involves the rape of someone under 18 years of age (75 percent), the pregnancy involves rape of someone over 18 (73 percent), the pregnancy is the result of incest (72 percent), the child will not survive long after birth (64 percent) or the child would be born with severe mental or physical defects (58 percent).
Americans are less supportive of abortions when a mother younger than 18 decides they just don’t want the child (46 percent), the mother or parents believe they aren’t capable of giving the child a good life (38 percent), raising the child would be a financial hardship to the mother or parents (37 percent), when a mother 18 or older decides they just don’t want the child (37 percent) or the mother wants a different gender (15 percent).
In each circumstance, those with a religious faith and those with evangelical beliefs are more likely than their counterparts to oppose abortion being legal. Those who attend church weekly are more likely than those who attend less frequently to oppose legal abortions in all but one situation.
Regardless of their personal opinions on abortion laws, 7 in 10 Americans (69 percent) say it is at least somewhat important to reduce the number of abortions in the U.S. in ways other than through the courts and legal system. Even among pro-abortion rights Americans, 54 percent believe reducing abortions is at least somewhat important.
“There are a lot of gradations in what abortion scenarios people think should be legal, but America is far from a majority supporting a legal right for an adult woman to have an abortion who just doesn’t want to have the child,” said McConnell. “The truth is Americans want fewer abortions taking place.”
When asked about potentially effective ways to reduce abortions, Americans are most likely to point to sex education, birth control and adoption. More than 2 in 5 say more birth control for minors (46 percent) and more and better sex education (44 percent) would be effective ways to reduce the number of abortions performed. Slightly fewer say promoting birth control to men (40 percent) or birth control for lower income individuals (39 percent). Close to a third point to promoting adoption as an option (36%), making adoption easier (36 percent), local organizations assisting mothers and children (34 percent) or more pregnancy counseling (33 percent).
Other ways Americans say are effective means to reduce the number of abortions include encouraging abstinence (27 percent), childcare for lower income families (27 percent), government help for low-income parents (22 percent), stronger legal limits on abortion (18 percent) and making it harder to find abortion providers (12 percent).
Opinions on Roe v. Wade
As Americans await a Supreme Court decision that could overturn Roe v. Wade, most say they’d prefer to keep the decision in place.
Two in 5 Americans (40 percent) say they completely support the Roe v. Wade Supreme Court decision. Another 1 in 5 (19 percent) mostly support it. One in 5 Americans (19 percent) completely oppose it, and 11 percent mostly oppose it. More than 1 in 10 (12 percent) say they aren’t sure or have no opinion.
Americans with no religious preference (76 percent), those without evangelical beliefs (66 percent), and Christians who don’t attend church (62 percent) or attend less regularly (60 percent) are all more likely to support Roe vs. Wade than not.
For those who oppose the Supreme Court decision, a quarter (26 percent) say a main reason is because children have rights, and 22 percent mention abortion is immoral. Around 1 in 5 (21 percent) say they oppose Roe vs. Wade because they believe abortion should be legal only in specific situations. Americans who support the decision overwhelmingly explain their reasoning goes back to a woman’s right to choose (71 percent).
Most Americans prefer a federal law on abortion for all states as opposed to leaving the issue up to the states. Those in the middle or unsure are more divided. Among the pro-life, 54 percent prefer a national law and 33 percent would rather leave it to each state. For the pro-abortion rights, 66 percent prefer a federal law for all states and 22 percent want each state to determine their own laws. Less than half of other Americans (48 percent) want a federal law, while 32 percent prefer individual state laws.
“Despite the many differences in Americans’ beliefs on abortion, there appears to be an innate desire for an unchanging legal standard,” McConnell said. “As the Supreme Court deliberates yet another change to the legal standard, evangelicals are among those who most want Roe v. Wade overturned. They are guided by a more static standard: the belief that the Bible is the highest authority for what they believe.”
A potential post-Roe future
When asked what they want to happen to Roe v. Wade, 40 percent completely support the decision and want it to remain, and 12 percent say it’s now the law of the land and should not be overturned. One in 5 Americans (20% percent) want it overturned and abortion made illegal nationwide, while 12 percent want it overturned and the laws left up to the states. Another 17 percent say they’re unsure or don’t have an opinion.
If Roe v. Wade is overturned, Americans are split on what should happen in individual states. More than a third (36 percent) want more restrictions on abortion, while the same percentage (36 percent) want to keep things like current federal law. More than 1 in 4 (28 percent) prefer easier access to abortion than currently exists.
In a post-Roe nation, 8 in 10 Americans (81 percent) say if a state government restricts abortion, it has a responsibility to increase support and options for women who have unwanted pregnancies. Almost 2 in 3 pro-life individuals (62 percent) agree.
Similarly, 3 in 4 Americans (74 percent), including 63 percent of pro-life Americans, say churches and religious organizations in states where abortion access is restricted after Roe v. Wade is overturned also have a responsibility to do more for women with unwanted pregnancies.
“The majority of Americans did not ask for Roe v. Wade to be overturned, but if it is, there is no national majority for any legislative path whether more or less restrictions or something similar to what has been in place,” McConnell said. “However, if more restrictions are put in place a large majority agrees the church and the state have a moral responsibility to help women with unwanted pregnancies.”
For more information, view the complete report.
Photo by Maria Oswalt on Unsplash